Bio
Gina Carroll is an author and freelance writer. She is currently a featured blogger at Chron.com, with Tortured by Teenagers: Parenting Adolescents w...
 
 
 
 

Most Popular

What's the Right Answer When Your Teen Asks If You've Ever Smoked Pot?

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 16
  • Sparkle (
    )
     
Marijuana Beign Rolled Into Cigarette  Marijuana Being Rolled Joint Cigarette

I've never smoked pot. Okay, I did take in plenty of secondhand smoke at the Hollywood Bowl during a few concerts, and at more than just a few house parties. But I never, ever took a hit! As a parent, this fact is one of the few things I do not have to sweat over when I’m talking with my kids about drug and alcohol use and other risk behaviors.

I think the cautionary conversations about risk behaviors are so much easier to have nowadays. We have so much more information about the ill-effects of illicit substances on growing bodies. And with kids so focused on celebrities, we have so many good (or bad, depending on how you look at it) examples of beloved film and music stars who have crashed and burned behind some dangerous habits and behaviors -- some fast and sudden, like Heath Ledger and Brad Renfro -- some slow and painful to witness, like Whitney Houston and Lindsay Lohan. So we can be clear and specific and stern with our warnings and our family limits.

But what happens when your kids ask you if you ever participated in such shenanigans? Inevitably, your teen will ask a tricky question such as:

  • Have you even tried marijuana?
  • How much did you party (i.e. drink) in high school? In college?
  • When did you lose your virginity?

Yikes! What do you say, and how much? Dr. Perri Klass addresses this dilemma in his New York Times article, Q. Did You Ever Smoke Pot? A. It’s Complicated. Dr. Klass highlights what a conflict this creates for parents who pride themselves on openness and honesty. You want to be frank, but not everyone’s story plays out like the perfect cautionary tale. You turned out just fine, after all. You may even have more fond memories than negative outcomes. So how do you tell the truth of your experiences and not create for your child what Klass describes as a "kind of I-did-it-and-I’m-fine parable?"

If you know anything about teens, you know that any admission of wrong-doing on the parents’ part will almost certainly come back to haunt them.

  • “Well, you did it. Why can’t I!”
  • “At least I’m not doing it as much (or as badly, or as stupidly) as you did!”
  • "Aren’t you being a hypocrite, Mom?”

According to the article, research shows the more parents provide information and the better they model appropriate behavior early in their children’s lives, the lower their children’s risk of substance abuse will be later on. According to TheAntiDrug.com, a teen drug and alcohol prevention website:

Kids who learn about the risks of drug use from their parents are 36 percent less likely to smoke marijuana than kids who learn nothing from them. If you talk to your kids about the dangers of drug use, they are also 50 percent less likely to use inhalants, and 56 percent less likely to use LSD - just because you took the time to talk to them. Research has also shown that kids want to hear what their parents have to say - in fact, 74 percent of fourth graders wish their parents would talk to them about drugs.

Apparently, this includes information about a parent’s own bad behavior. Another recent study cited in the Klass article said that "many teenagers believed that parental honesty about alcohol use was a positive influence." So how do you sort out what to say and how? The following are the suggestions put forth by Klass and the pediatricians and psychologists she relies upon in her article:

1. Every family is different and there are no fixed rules about whether to disclose or to what extent. The important thing to find out is why your child is asking. Ask him or her why they are asking and try to ascertain what is going on in their world to inspire such questions.

2. If you decide to disclose, take into account your child’s developmental age. "You answer a question from a 12-year-old and a 22-year-old in different terms and in different detail," says Dr. Janet F. Williams, professor of pediatrics at University of Texas Health Science Center at San Antonio.

  1. 3. There is a wide, wide space between denying the truth and telling every detail. You don’t have to tell them
  • 16
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Gina Carroll 5 pts

Holy Smokes, Vicki! Thanks for catching that. I feel terrible that I misrepresented this wonderful and prolific woman--physician, writer, expert and mother. The last thing I want to do is fail to count her as one of our own!

Contributing Editor Gina Carroll also blogs at Think Act: Proactive Black Parenting  ( http://www.proactiveblackparenting.blogspot.com/ )and 

PauleyD 5 pts

I can't expect my kids to be truthful and honest with me if I don't treat them with the same respect.

Do as I say not as I do does not exist in my home.

VickiForman 5 pts

Great piece! Minor comment: Perri Klass is a woman!

Gina Carroll 5 pts

Justlinda,
I think teen pregnancy is the toughest one to discuss with your kids, because of the need to discuss your past without making the child feel like a mistake or an unwanted accident.

And I agree with you about the desire to remain in control. My father was a probation officer by profession, so the fear of being arrested was well ingrained in my brother and I. But besides that, I always joke that I work too hard and long before a party to look cute. There is no way you can be cute and sexy at any gathering with a straw up your nose for cocaine or with your eyes red and at half mass from pot! And there is nothing less attractive than a sloppy drunk woman!

In essence, it's vanity that keeps me clean and sober!

Contributing Editor Gina Carroll also blogs at Think Act: Proactive Black Parenting  ( http://www.proactiveblackparenting.blogspot.com/ )and Tortured By Teenagers  ( http://momhouston.com/torturedbyteenagers/ )

justlinda 10 pts

My oldest two are in their mid-20s so I've been through it a bit with them. I have 3 more coming up behind and expect I'll face it again.

As for the virginity one, well, there isn't a corner dark enough for me to hide regarding that... I got pregnant at 17 and my firstborn came when I was 18. As soon as my kids are old enough to do simple math, they can sort that one out. haha But more than that, I wear it on my sleeve - my experiences are who I am. Plus, with 5 daughters, I hope they can absorb through me some of what I learned going through the hardship of teen parenthood and teen marriage.

As for the pot one? Yeah, sure. I've tried it. I wouldn't hide that from them, either. I did not like it. Maybe if I was a lover-of-pot, I'd need to think through how I'd talk to my kids. Good for me that I'm not.

My standard response to that is "I don't need an illegal substance to help me eat a box of Twinkies and fall asleep - I can do THAT all on my own!"

I also talk about how it's important to me to remain in control of my behavior. That often times, people who are stoned or drunk make idiots out of themselves and how I'm not secure enough to let myself be an idiot. Or maybe that I'm enough of an idiot on my own that I don't trust how much more idiotness I would display under the influence.

And then I cross my fingers, knock on wood, and pray to a god I'm not even sure I believe in. THAT'S my parenting strategy...

JustLinda

fabulously imperfect Nothing to See Here... Just Linda ( http://justlinda.net )

Twitter @JustLindaSTL

Melissa Ford 5 pts

We are quite big into honesty (makes remembering what you said easier), but I do think it's wise to not tell the whole story. To answer just the facts, ma'am.

Melissa writes Stirrup Queens ( http://stirrup-queens.com ) and Lost and Found ( http://lostandfoundandconnectionsabound.blogspot.c... ). Her book is Navigating the Land of If ( http://thelandofif.blogspot.com/ ).

thepsychobabble 5 pts

I plan to be honest. As in "This is the choice I made regarding Topic A/B/C. This is how that worked out for me, and this is why I hope that you will be able to learn from my past, be able to avoid the same mistakes and the consequences of them."

LionessWoman 5 pts

I like your suggestion of what to say. I wish i had that around when my son asked me that question.

Lioness Womans Club http://www.lionesswomansclub.com

redheadedjen 5 pts

My parents were 20 in 1968. Maybe that says it all but my Dad was very open with us regarding his wild past. He talked about taking speed, LSD (and how we got some Dr. Suess and other story records handed down to us- bought to listen to while taking LSD), pot, etc.

I personally have never smoke anything. I've never had the desire to. Dad did it in hopes that he would either scare us away with his various tales or as in my case, I would like vicariously through him.

Gina Carroll 5 pts

I am a little fixated about generally accepted notions of truth. I've posted about it a few times because I think it's interesting how societal notions of honesty have increasingly shifted off-center. I believe most of us are less honest than we think.

A parenting issue like this, when your own honesty can be a sort of Catch 22, is where the rubber meets the road. You can't always tell the truth AND keep your pristine image in tact. Sometimes you have to make a choice.

I greatly respect those of you who step up, take the hit and tell the truth. I have to believe the lesson in honesty and transparency will always be the enduring one.

Contributing Editor Gina Carroll also blogs at Think Act: Proactive Black Parenting  ( http://www.proactiveblackparenting.blogspot.com/ )and Tortured By Teenagers ( http://momhouston.com/torturedbyteenagers )

Hey Jen 5 pts

I'm very open and honest about many of the things I've done as a kid. But they also know how much trouble and how messed up of a life their father leads due to excessive drinking and drug use.

babybeatnik 5 pts

I am age-appropriately honest with my kids. When my daughter Gracie was 2.5 months old, my husband and I got arrested because he was selling pot. We lost Gracie (she was placed in my mom's custody) for a little over a year while we worked on turning our lives around.

As horrible as the situation was, we're lucky that it wasn't worse. I heard about several people in town shortly after whose houses were robbed, who got assaulted and horribly injured. I can't imagine how bad I would feel had that happened while Gracie was home.

At any rate - we changed everything around and 5 years later things are wonderful. Gracie knows that when she was a baby she lived with her Mimi and when the time comes, I will use our story to hopefully persuade her and her sister from using drugs.

My story can be read here: http://beatniksbeatonlife.blogspot.com/2010/02/eve... ( http://beatniksbeatonlife.blogspot.com/2010/02/eve... )

emilysteers 5 pts

my parents were and still are exceedingly honest about their drug intakes. and i appreciate at that a lot. i know they'd never punish me for one or two stupid mistakes (save DUI's-- that's completely unforgivable. but getting stoned and getting caught? they'd shrug & pay bail.) they also understand that drugs are engineered to be more potent and potentially more dangerous NOW than they were in the 70s. mom's advice when heading to my first music festival? "roll your own, sweetie."

mom was also exceedingly honest about the effects of drugs, considering she was a psychiatric social worker for some time. several of her patients were on permanent LSD trips. so, uh, no thanks.

 -emily

www.happyhomeblog.com
( http://www.happyhomeblog.com )

PeevedMichelle 5 pts

My answer is, "No," because I never did. My dad was a pothead and that was a pretty effective deterrant for me and I plan to use his loser life story as a deterrant for my children.

Csamuels 5 pts

I remember sitting by the Hudson River with both kids before they were in double digits even. I had always told them that I would never lie to them. SO when one of them asked me about pot, I said yes, I had used it and that I thought that to try it while you were really young was a bad idea but that they could always talk to us about it. I also told them that we would always pick them up if they got stuck someplace and didn't want to stay. We were lucky in NY because nobody was ever driving.

One of them is still a Deadhead and had his moments but we always knew about it and talked about it. I realize now when I see other friends with kids who've been in trouble w/drugs for years that we really dodged a bullet but I just didn't feel I could lie and I still think I was right.

I got smarter w/the second kid and asked him to wait until he was at least 16 and he did.

I recommend honesty because by the time you need trust between you and your kid it's awfully late to start trying to build it.

Cynthia Samuels, Partner
Cobblestone Associates, LLP
Blog and Media Strategies and Content Development Online and on Television   

Don’t
Gel Too Soon ( http://dontgelyet.typepad.com/dontgeltoosoon )

lisanoel03 5 pts

I am a living breathing cautionary tale, and so is my husband. My kids already know way more than a 6 and 7 year old should know about alcohol and the effects of drinking too much. Who knows what that will mean for them but we have agreed that we will be completely honest about our experiences and simply do our best to explain that yes we did it but we really hope you'll learn a lesson from us and not have to repeat our mistakes. I guess if our lives were "picture perfect" I may second guess this theory because they could look at us and figure "hey, if they did and turned out ok it can't be THAT bad." but our kids know how much we struggle and that we are in a neighborhood we'd give our right arm to be out of because of issues resulting from my husbands alcohol abuse. I didn't finish college because of severe depression which may not have been solely caused by but was certainly worsened by a pregnancy I terminated.
We already use our stories to educate others in our church etc and simply plan to continue to do so with our kids!