Bio
Alanna Kellogg is the second-generation author of Kitchen Parade, a food and recipe column that features seasonal recipes for every-day healthful eat...
 
 
 
 

What’s Hot on BlogHer.com

Yuck or Yum: Lower-Fat Products Worth Buying

  • Share This Post
  • Pin It
  • 15
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

(No) thanks to recession, more of us are cooking at home. But how often does this mean standing at the grocery store, staring with glassy eyes at a shelf of mind-numbingly similar products, wondering just which one to buy? It's an easy choice, selecting the full-fat versions of some of these products. But really, are the lower-fat versions just as good? Here are some of the lower-fat products that I think are worth buying -- the ones that are just a little bit healthier, but where the taste is just as good, or so close, to the full-fat versions.

Much to my surprise, my favorite lower-fat products are mostly -- though not always -- found in the dairy case.

Milk Milk is the number one source of calcium, a nutrient that's particularly essential for women's bone strength. I'm so accustomed to skim milk that even 1% and 2% milk have a mouthfeel that's 'too fatty' for my taste. But if skim milk is too 'thin' for you, then the lower-fat versions of milk have considerably fewer calories and reduced saturated fat -- but might meet the taste test that means you'll drink enough milk.

NUTRITION ESTIMATE for 1 cup Whole Milk: 146Cal; 7g Tot Fat; 4g Sat Fat; 24mg Cholesterol; 97mg Sodium; 11g Carb; 0g Fiber; 13g Sugar; 9g Protein; Weight Watchers 2 points

NUTRITION ESTIMATE for 1 cup 2% Milk: 122Cal; 5g Tot Fat; 2g Sat Fat; 19mg Cholesterol; 100mg Sodium; 11g Carb; 0g Fiber; 12g Sugar; 8g Protein; Weight Watchers 2 points

NUTRITION ESTIMATE for 1 cup 1% Milk: 102Cal; 2g Tot Fat; 2g Sat Fat; 12mg Cholesterol; 107mg Sodium; 12g Carb; 0g Fiber; 13g Sugar; 8g Protein; Weight Watchers 2 points

NUTRITION ESTIMATE for 1 cup Skim Milk: 85Cal; 0g Tot Fat; 0g Sat Fat; 4mg Cholesterol; 127mg Sodium; 12g Carb; 0g Fiber; 12g Sugar; 8g Protein; Weight Watchers 1 point

NOTE: Nutrition estimates were calculated with MacGourmet.

Another thought: try different brands of milk, they're don't all taste the same. I've become a huge fan of the skim milk from Farmers' All Natural Creamery, whose milk is pasteurized but not homogenized -- this means that it takes a good shake before drinking. It tastes sooo good that at night, I'll pour a glass in a wine glass, it's that heavenly! It 'tastes' like whole milk to me, plus sweeter, milkier, grassier.

Sour Cream The lower-fat versions of sour cream are very good, worth purchasing, especially for baking but even for dolloping onto a baked potato, say. The non-fat versions of sour cream? Gooey gummy yuck.

Mayonnaise The lower-fat versions of mayonnaise are often good, worth purchasing. I'm a particular fan of Hellmann's light mayonnaise, which has half the fat and calories of the full-fat Hellmann's Real Mayonnaise. (Note: Hellmann's is also branded Best Foods in some parts of the country.) The non-fat versions of of mayonnaise? Gloppy yuck.

Half & Half Dare I say? I love the Land O' Lakes non-fat half & half -- but mostly for morning coffee. It has no thickening properties, so doesn't work for making ice cream, custard or even scalloped potatoes. It does work beautifully as a creamy addition for a milk-based soup, my favorite salmon chowder, say.

Cream Cheese Here's a great find -- the reduced fat cream cheese, also called 'Neufchatel'. It works so well, I never ever buy full-fat cream cheese anymore. Non-fat cream cheese? Gummy yuck.

Peanut Butter I'm a fan of the low-carb peanut butter, where the sugar has been replaced by Splenda. But -- more and more these days -- I turn to a full-fat but no-sugar peanut butter, truly luscious in my morning oatmeal, one tiny spoonful at a time.

Canned Fruit While fresh fruit is great,there are times when canned fruit is useful, for making a Winter Fruit Salad, say. Forget canned fruit in heavy syrup, it's all about the sugar, masking the fruit, entirely. Instead, select canned fruit in its own juice, or in light syrup. You'll save calories, eliminate unneeded sugar and actually taste the fruit.

WHAT ABOUT THESE LOWER-FAT PRODUCTS?

Butter Substitutes I've only begun to explore the butter alternatives -- products like Smart Balance, Earth Balance and the like. What's your experience? Are they any good, for baking? for eating? for what?

Cheese For some reason, low-fat cheese creeps me out. How does it work for you?

WHAT MY FELLOW BLOGGERS THINK ABOUT LOWER-FAT PRODUCTS

Twitter Links
(NOTE: Every so often, my fellow

  • 15
  • Sparkle (
    )
     

Comments

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Sally K 5 pts

Thanks for the welcome, Alanna!  It's good to be here. 

You're right -- all dairy is processed.  Meat is, too.  I'm not against reduced fat products when all that's been done is the fat reduced.  But once things are added to mimic the taste and/or texture of the real thing, then it's off my list of acceptable things to eat.

My current gripe is pre-shredded cheeses (regardless of the fat content).  A starch is added to prevent caking.  Now they're off my list and I'm shredding my own.  I'm not thrilled about food coloring added, either. 

So much has been added to our food supply and I don't think most of it is healthy.    

akawest 5 pts

I buy six fat free half and halfs every other week. Not only is it a perfect addition to coffee, it is yummy in oatmeal, and makes instant pudding mix puff up in a delightfully tasty manner.

Sally K 5 pts

I use 2% milk and a couple of other low-fat dairy products.  As soon as they have to add modifiers and other things to make it taste right and be the right texture or consistency, it's out of my refrigerator or cupboard.  Nutritional science is still truly in its infancy.  The scientists and researchers find something to blame our health and weight problems on, and the food industry responds with another reduced-fat, reduced-carb, chemically altered food.As our consumption of these foods has increased, at home or at restaurants, so has our weight and various health issues.  The more the food industry cranks out new products, the fatter and unhealthier we get.  There's almost a direct correlation between the increasing intake of these foods and our increasing health and weight problems since the beginning of the 20th century, but even more after the 1960s.    I think that at some point in the future the scientists are going to find that not only overly refined and processed foods and chemical additives, but also altered foods (fat-reduced, carb-reduced, etc) are at the root of our problems with heart disease, type 2 diabetes, various cancers, obesity and so on.In The Perfect Recipe for Losing Weight & Eating Great, Pam Anderson recalls being at a family reunion and looking at pictures of family members from the 1950s and 1960s.  No one was fat.  What's different between now and then?  More overly refined and processed foods.  Oh, and we eat more and exercise less.I think part of the reason that we eat more is that these foods don't satisfy us and they're less than adequate nutritionally.I'm not sure that refined grains are problematic.  I've read a lot about various indigenous or traditional diets.  The Asians eat tons of white rice and those in the Mediterranean consume more white flour products and they're healthier -- and slimmer --  than we are.  But they eat these in combination with whole grains and other whole foods cooked at home.    Reduced fat and reduced carb products have been absent from their diets.  The biggest difference between any of them and us is the absence of overly refined and processed foods and altered food products.  They're not eating Rice-A-Roni or Pasta-Roni that cooks in a few minutes and comes with a flavor packet.    As the overly refined and processed foods are added to their diets, they become equally as unhealthy and fat as we are.  What's particularly interesting to me about this is how it all affects heart disease.  I have heart disease.  The only time my total cholesterol has ever been elevated is when my diet was higher in refined and processed foods and reduced fat products.  About two years ago I started eliminating all this stuff from my diet -- and eating a little more more meat (but still only averaging 1 serving daily) and using butter.  I was due to have lab work done, and briefly considered cancelling the appointment because I was sure my cholsterol would be elevated.  I decided to go ahead with it and if cholesterol was elevated, I'd just tell them what I'd been doing and go back to my old ways.  To my surprise, it was almost 10% lower than it had been at the previous testing!   I am on a low dose of a statin, but even so, I think cholesterol would have gone up instead of down when I switched to full fat products. If we want to consume less fat, we should eat less of the foods containing it, not reduced-fat products (and more and more of them).  What I've found to be interesting is that when I eat the full fat products and other "real" foods, I'm satisfied with less food.  Maybe it's like the old Parkay margarine advertisement said: it's not nice to fool Mother Nature.

I Wanna Be A Celeb 5 pts

I'll low fat almost anything but butter. I use less of it, obviously, because of the calories, but the contents of margarine scare me. I do use butter spray for cooking though,usually I Can't Believe It's Not Butter.

http://iwannabeacelebbutimtoopoortoaffordit.blogsp...

http://lvmomssincity.blogspot.com/

sandhillsis 5 pts

We're only here for a short time. I want my life to be full of health-so I exercise,  and full of love--so I try to love unconditional. Why is food any different? Natural fats in moderation won't kill you, but stressing about them might. :0)

I like the way the Italians do IT. Full flavors, wine and family have seemly caused them to live healthier longer.

Whatever IT is...I'll have some. Simply, Sis

www.reclaimsimplicity.com ( http://www.reclaimsimplicity.com/

Discover how rich and hilarious life can be when it's simple. Tales and tips on making money mind, riding the recycle, simple food, homegrown music, gardening and more.

sassymonkey 6 pts

I swear I don't specifically make trips to Vermont to maybe buy about $50US worth of the stuff and bring it back to Canada. No. Not me. I'd never do that.

And yes, I'd forgotten that their low-fat cheese is scrumdiddlyumptious. I stand corrected. :)

Sassymonkey ( http://sassymonkey.ca/ ) and Sassymonkey Reads ( http://sassymonkeyreads.ca/ ).

sassymonkey 6 pts

Except in milk. While I grew up on whole milk I now drink either 1% or skim. (There was an evolution thing going on there, I swear.)

Have you tried searching for yogurt that's not low fat lately? It's hard to find. I've mostly given up.

And I'm sorry, there's no butter substitute. There's butter and there's other stuff. End of story.

Sassymonkey ( http://sassymonkey.ca/ ) and Sassymonkey Reads ( http://sassymonkeyreads.ca/ ).

tinykorean 5 pts

I love this article, because so much of it is true! I've come to really love the non-fat sour cream, lowfat milk and lowfat mayo. They're excellent, and are very very similarin taste. The non-fat sour cream tends to "melt" more easily during cooking, but that might be a good thing depending on what you're making.

Non-fat cheese is not the same. At all. I hate it and it's disgusting, but I still suffer through it for the most part. Butter is not at all the same in consistency, but I've never been able to taste a difference in baking/cooking.

- Anneli | http://tinykorean.com

Vered 5 pts

We use full-fat stuff in small quantities. I find the full-fat versions are tastier and are more satisfying, so a little goes a long way. Our cholesterol levels are fine and we do exercise regularly, stay away from trans fats, and eat lots of fruit and veggies.

----

A Mommy Blogger ( http://momgrind.com/ ) and a Blogger For Hire ( http://momgrind.com/hire-me/ )

KBestOliver 5 pts

Great idea for a post.  I drink skim milk all the time anyway--we buy organic, including the brand you mentioned, and it's often less "watery" than conventional skim.  I also like and actively use low-fat sour cream, low and nonfat yogurt (depending on the brand; I like Wallaby), and low-fat cream cheese.  Low-fat cheese?  No, thanks, except maybe string cheese.  Also, I prefer to use butter and cream in moderate quantities when it really impacts the flavor. I hate, hate, hate the taste of margarine and will not use it.

I have Elie Krieger's cookbook, and she usually doesn't use low/no fat substitutes except milk, instead modifying the amount of full fat ingredients to maximize flavor.  I tend to agree with her.  I like "real" food, not food full of chemicals or additives, but I hate artificial sweetners more than I hate low/no fat foods. I think the important thing is to try different versions and see what you like and what you don't.  Some people's limits are different than others.

Asthmagirl 5 pts

Although I will never give up butter (just reduced the amounts used) and I have only worked my way down to low fat mayonaise, I do non fat pretty much everything else including sour cream. Tillamook non fat sour cream is to die for.... tasty, sturdy (not runny) and guilt free!

Mir Kamin 6 pts

... I have to share that the Cabot low-fat cheddar cheese ( https://www.shopcabot.com/pages/products/light.php ) has recently rocked my world. It's delicious, and I normally turn up my nose at low-fat cheeses because they just taste all wrong. But the Cabot, I dunno, maybe it's got heroin in it. It's GOOD. And we've even served it side-by-side with regular cheese and had folks unable to figure out which one was low-fat.

--
Mir Kamin
(BlogHer contributing editor)

Personal: Woulda Coulda Shoulda ( http://wouldashoulda.com/ )

Having it all with less: Want Not ( http://wantnot.net/ )

Alanna 5 pts

Trust me, I'm not advocating a wholesale change from full-fat to lower-fat or non-fat!

I do think that some -- not all, but some -- products serve good purpose.

Alanna Kellogg
Kitchen Parade ( http://kitchenparade.com/ ) &
A Veggie Venture ( http://kitchen-parade-veggieventure.blogspot.com/ )

Alanna 5 pts

So glad it works for you, thanks for the pudding tip.

Alanna Kellogg
Kitchen Parade ( http://kitchenparade.com/ ) &
A Veggie Venture ( http://kitchen-parade-veggieventure.blogspot.com/ )

Alanna 5 pts

And thank you for moving your comment off e-mail onto BlogHer! You bring up excellent points about 'processed' foods, thanks for adding that to the conversation. I'm in complete agreement -- but at least to my sensibility, removing fat from milk, say, doesn't make skim milk a 'processed' product and thus deserves a place in our diets.

(In fact, with pasteurization and homogenization, all milk is 'processed', yes?)

Alanna Kellogg
Kitchen Parade ( http://kitchenparade.com/ ) &
A Veggie Venture ( http://kitchen-parade-veggieventure.blogspot.com/ )